The Psychology of Infidelity: Part 3 – Understanding Why Affairs Happen

The Fundamental Question: Why?

“Why?” This is invariably the first question asked when infidelity is discovered. It erupts from a place of shock, pain, and desperate need to make sense of a world suddenly turned upside down. The person who has been betrayed searches frantically for understanding—seeking to locate the cause in themselves, their partner, their relationship, or the third party.

While this question is natural, it often leads us down problematic paths. Asking “why” can mislead us into thinking there’s a single, specific reason the affair happened. The reality is much more complex. More likely, multiple factors contributed to the affair, and the person who had the affair may not even fully understand all their motivations.

To approach infidelity with greater wisdom, we must reframe our understanding, looking beyond the act to the larger context and meaning. This doesn’t excuse betrayal but helps us understand it in ways that can lead to healing.

Naming What Happened

Before we can understand why infidelity occurred, we must first clarify exactly what happened. This seemingly straightforward task often becomes complicated by attempts to minimize, rationalize, or avoid painful truths.

Several key questions can help bring clarity:

1. What happened? Establishing the basic facts is essential, though sometimes tricky when details emerge gradually or deception continues.

2. What do you believe happened? Facts and perceptions don’t always align. Someone might believe infidelity occurred even when it technically didn’t, or might deny certain aspects despite clear evidence.

3. What do you believe the events reveal? The meaning attributed to infidelity often causes more pain than the acts themselves. Does the affair represent a fundamental betrayal of trust? A symptom of relationship problems? A character flaw? These interpretations shape the emotional impact.

4. What do you believe the events say about your partner? When infidelity is discovered, it often causes the betrayed person to question everything they thought they knew about their partner. Were they ever truly the person you believed them to be?

5. What do you believe the events indicate about you? Many betrayed partners internalize infidelity as a reflection on themselves—evidence they weren’t enough in some way. This self-blame compounds the trauma.

6. What name or label do you give to what happened? The language we use shapes our experience. Terms like “cheating,” “affair,” “betrayal,” and “infidelity” carry different connotations and emotional charges.

The Evolution of Infidelity

Contrary to popular imagination, infidelity rarely happens suddenly. While the discovery may be immediate and devastating, the affair itself typically develops gradually through a series of small decisions, boundary erosion, and missed opportunities for connection.

Understanding this evolution requires examining:

1. When did it start versus when did it happen? The technical act of infidelity may have occurred at a specific moment, but the emotional and psychological groundwork was likely laid much earlier.

2. Where did the infidelity occur? The physical locations where affairs develop—workplaces, social media, old connections—can reveal necessary information about vulnerabilities and needs.

3. How did it develop? Affairs typically follow patterns of increasing intimacy and boundary violations. Recognizing these patterns can help prevent future betrayals.

4. With whom did it begin? The choice of affair partner often reveals unmet needs or unresolved issues from the primary relationship.

5. What did the affair provide that was appealing? Understanding the emotional, psychological, or physical payoffs is crucial for healing and prevention.

6. What did the affair provide that the person wished their partner could have given? This painful but essential question helps identify gaps in the primary relationship.

7. What was being communicated through the affair? Affairs often represent attempts to express needs or feelings that aren’t being addressed directly.

8. What was needed or wanted? At its core, infidelity usually stems from unmet needs—for attention, validation, excitement, intimacy, or escape.

9. What damage has been caused and to whom? Acknowledging the full scope of harm—to the betrayed partner, the relationship, children, extended family, and even to the person who had the affair—is an essential step toward healing.

The Nature of Infidelity

To understand why affairs happen, we must understand what infidelity fundamentally is:

1. Infidelity is a traumatic event. For the person experiencing betrayal, infidelity triggers the body’s trauma response. The central nervous system activates into fight-or-flight mode, creating intense physiological and psychological reactions that can persist for months or even years.

2. Infidelity is not necessarily about sex. At its core, infidelity is about need: “I need to feel a certain way. I need to have something else or another person. I need to send a message about what I deserve. I need to send a message about your lack.”

3. Infidelity is fundamentally a breach of trust. However, the violated expectations may have been implied rather than explicitly discussed. Many couples never clearly define their boundaries and assumptions about exclusivity.

4. Infidelity distorts orientation to time. The person who committed the act will often focus primarily on the future—on moving forward and leaving the past behind. The person who has been betrayed typically becomes intensely focused on the past—replaying events, searching for clues they missed, and trying to reconstruct a timeline of deception.

5. Infidelity is evidence of a death. Sometimes it reveals that something in the relationship has run its course or that certain illusions about the relationship can no longer be maintained.

The Comprehensive Impact of Infidelity

When infidelity occurs, it affects every dimension of human experience:

Physiological Effects

Shortness of breath
Elevated blood pressure
Dizziness and light-headedness
Digestive disturbances
Sleep disruption
Possible exposure to STIs

Psychological Effects

Shock and disbelief
Confusion and disorientation
Intrusive and obsessive thoughts
Difficulty concentrating
Paranoia and hypervigilance
Suicidal or homicidal ideation in severe cases
Poor judgment and decision-making

Emotional Effects

Rage and anger
Anxiety and fear
Irritability and mood swings
Profound sadness and grief
Emotional withdrawal
Depression and feelings of hopelessness
Shame and humiliation

Spiritual Effects

Crisis of faith
Questioning of core beliefs
Loss of meaning and purpose
Sense of spiritual abandonment
Disconnection from spiritual practices
Questioning one’s understanding of reality

Moral/Ethical Effects

Questioning previously held values
Temptation toward revenge or retaliation
Acting in ways that conflict with personal ethics
Moral confusion and disorientation
Re-evaluation of ethical frameworks

Relational and Social Impacts

Infidelity ripples outward, affecting not just the couple but their entire social ecosystem:

Relationship with Self

Identity confusion
Self-doubt and questioning
Diminished self-esteem and self-worth
Disconnection from one’s body and emotions
Questioning one’s judgment and perceptions

Relationship with Partner

Profound distrust and suspicion
Communication breakdown
Emotional and physical withdrawal
Anger and contempt
Desire for revenge
Loss of shared history and meaning

Relationships with Others

Withdrawal from family and friends
Embarrassment and shame in social settings
Triangulation of others into the conflict
Emotional fusion with sympathetic allies
Difficulty trusting others generally
Isolation to avoid judgment or questions

Relationship with Institutions

Cynicism toward marriage and commitment
Distrust of religious or cultural teachings
Feeling betrayed by societal norms and expectations
Questioning previously respected authorities

Relationship with Gender

Generalizing negative experiences (“All men cheat” or “All women are untrustworthy”)
Gender-based mistrust and resentment
Reinforcement of harmful stereotypes
Difficulty forming new relationships

Common Factors Contributing to Infidelity

While every affair is unique, research has identified several common factors that increase vulnerability to infidelity:

1. Individual Factors

History of childhood trauma or attachment injuries
Previous experiences of betrayal
Family patterns of infidelity
Narcissistic or sensation-seeking personality traits
Difficulty with emotional intimacy
Substance abuse issues
Untreated mental health conditions

2. Relationship Factors

Chronic conflict or emotional disconnection
Sexual incompatibility or dissatisfaction
Emotional neglect or abandonment
Power imbalances
Major life transitions (parenthood, relocation, career changes)
Financial stress
Physical separation due to work or other circumstances

3. Situational Factors

Work environments with close opposite-sex colleagues
Business travel and prolonged separation
Social settings with normalized infidelity
Availability of potential partners
Technology facilitating secret communications
Life crises or transitions (midlife crisis, empty nest)

4. Cultural Factors

Media normalization or glamorization of affairs
Contradictory messages about sexuality and monogamy
Cultural devaluation of long-term commitment
Hypersexualized environments
Historical trauma affecting community norms around sexuality (as discussed in Part 2)

Types of Affairs and Their Meanings

Not all affairs are created equal. Understanding the different types can provide insight into the underlying dynamics:

1. The Conflict-Avoidance Affair

This type of affair serves as an escape from addressing significant problems in the primary relationship. Rather than facing complex issues directly, the person seeks comfort and validation elsewhere.

2. The Intimacy-Avoidance Affair

Paradoxically, some affairs help maintain emotional distance in the primary relationship. When intimacy becomes threatening due to past trauma or vulnerability fears, an affair can create a “safe” outlet for sexual or emotional connection while preserving emotional barriers with the primary partner.

3. The Sexual Addiction or Compulsion Affair

For some individuals, affairs represent a manifestation of compulsive sexual behavior patterns that exist independently of relationship satisfaction. These affairs typically follow escalating patterns and may occur regardless of the quality of the primary relationship.

a. The Cry for Help Affair

Sometimes an affair represents an unconscious attempt to bring attention to serious problems in the relationship. The person may not know how to address their needs directly or may have tried unsuccessfully to communicate them.

5. The Exit Affair

Some affairs serve primarily as a transition out of an unwanted relationship. The affair provides both the motivation and justification for ending the primary relationship when the person lacks the courage or clarity to leave directly.

6. The Fantasy Affair

This affair is primarily about escape from ordinary life rather than specific relationship dissatisfaction. It provides excitement, novelty, and adventure that may be lacking in the relationship and the person’s life generally.

7. The Self-Expansion Affair

Some affairs occur when a person encounters someone who facilitates access to new aspects of themselves—qualities, interests, or potentials they haven’t been able to express in their primary relationship or current life circumstances.

8. The Revenge Affair

Occasionally, affairs happen specifically to retaliate for a partner’s actual or perceived betrayal or neglect. These affairs are explicitly meant to cause pain and often represent accumulated resentment.

Reframing Infidelity: Finding Meaning in Pain

While infidelity causes tremendous suffering, it can also—with proper support and commitment to growth—become a catalyst for profound transformation. Some potential reframes include:

1. Reality check: Infidelity often exposes truths about the relationship that were previously denied or ignored. While painful, this clarity can ultimately lead to healthier choices.

2. Myth buster: Affairs frequently shatter idealized notions about relationships, partners, or oneself. While initially devastating, this disillusionment can lead to more mature and realistic understandings.

3. Truth-telling opportunity: Affairs often bring unspoken needs, desires, and dissatisfactions that have been buried to light. While the method of revelation is destructive, the content of what’s revealed can be valuable for growth.

4. Catalyst for authentic communication: Many couples report that after the crisis of infidelity, they begin communicating with a level of honesty and vulnerability they never achieved before. The affair breaks down facades and pretenses.

5. Invitation to self-discovery: For the betrayed partner, infidelity often prompts profound questioning about personal values, boundaries, and needs that may have been neglected. This painful process can lead to greater self-awareness and assertiveness.

6. Opportunity for conscious choice: Rather than continuing in a relationship out of habit or obligation, infidelity forces both partners to actively choose whether to stay or leave. This conscious decision-making can lead to deeper commitment or necessary endings.

7. Chance to redefine relationship terms: The aftermath of infidelity requires establishing new agreements, which can create space for more authentic and mutually satisfying relationship structures than what existed before.

8. Growth through adversity: Surviving the trauma of infidelity develops resilience, emotional depth, and coping skills that can serve both individuals in all areas of life, regardless of whether the relationship continues.

9. Relationship reset: Some couples describe infidelity as a painful but necessary “burning down” of an unhealthy relationship structure, creating space to build something entirely new with the same partner.

10. Compassion cultivator: Working through infidelity often develops greater compassion—for oneself, one’s partner, and human frailty in general. This expanded compassion can enhance all relationships moving forward.

While none of these reframes diminish the pain and trauma of betrayal, they offer perspectives that can help both partners extract meaning from suffering and potentially transform a devastating experience into an opportunity for profound growth and healing.

Next Installment: The Psychology of Infidelity: Part 4 – Healing and Moving Forward

FREE SHOCK RACIAL TRAUMA WEBINAR: https://t.ly/3ja4Y

“I just completed a brief session with ChatGPT-Black Trauma. Wow! The responses I got were soooooo helpfu!.” — John Jackson (Patreon Member)

At BlackTraumaGPT.com, we aim to foster healing, understanding, and empowerment within Black communities by providing culturally sensitive education, insights, and mental health resources. We aim to deepen the collective awareness of Black trauma’s historical roots and its contemporary manifestations while guiding individuals and communities toward paths of self-care, resilience, and holistic healing. By leveraging the wisdom of Africana phenomenology and the expertise of Black scholars, we support the transformation of trauma into strength, encouraging collective growth and thriving.

IT’S TIME TO BREAK BLACK TRAUMA! Heal Thyself @ BlackTraumaGPT.com http://blacktraumagpt.com/ ASK THE QUESTION(S)!

———————

Get Social with Doc SHOCK:

SHOCKmetaphysics.com

Healing Racial Black Trauma in the Diaspora from the MAAFA